Now that I've seen both do the Queen thing live, the shows were both wonderful and different in their own ways but my vote is still for Rodgers. The QAL experience was more Queen focused, no other artist's songs were performed, a campy frontman who can sing the hell out of those songs, but something that bothered me was the people in the audience who seemed bored when Adam wasn't on stage (during Days of Our Lives and Brian's solo, for example). I'm thinking how DARE you not appreciate what you're witnessing
At the show with Paul everyone was on the same page, both fanbases together eating up every moment. There was a distinction between Paul as himself with Brian and Roger.. if that makes sense. No crown, no Freddie-like behavior.